Nuts & Bolts
Business of Freelancing


Can Writers Learn to Be Funny?

By Mary Collins, WIW Board Member

“Mom, your hair looks like the Everything Bagel,” my 10-year-old daughter said, which was funny, at least I thought so initially, until I realized that most Everything Bagels are covered with lots of white salt.

I hadn’t planned to write a humor column about whether or not I should color my hair now that I am in my mid-forties, but people kept saying the most unfortunate things about my hair.

So I started keeping a file. A year went by and I had enough anecdotes to pen a 1,000-word first-person essay, complete with the Everything Bagel quotation, which wound up in the middle somewhere near a reference to the color of uncooked chicken breasts.

I sold the piece to The Washington Post StylePlus page, a great place to submit if you like to write light humor about things in everyday life.

In my classes I try to convince my students that they can do the same thing: Keep a file of funny things that relate to one specific topic and then pull it together in a short essay. Of course, most people tell me with a very straight face, “I’m not funny.” Of course, well, I believe them.

But should I? Every few semesters I have a funny class where we spend a third of our time finding everything incredibly hilarious (especially the writing process). When I think of funny student Holly Smith (who published her work in Salon and had an essay reprinted in The Best Contemporary Humor: Mirth of A Nation) immediately comes to mind.

She’s not convinced that a person can “learn” humor.

“You might be able to get him to suck the gravitas out of his work here and there, but it probably won’t feel very good to him,” said Smith.

So funny is born not made.

“I think its overall rhythm almost needs to be felt. It’s kind of like poetry that way,” Smith said. “It’s also like poetry in that humor writers can generally be found in the unemployment line right behind the poets.”

The fiction students I queried felt a bit more optimistic. When I asked Fiction Advisor Mark Farrington to name some funny students, he mentioned Dave Housley, who told me via e-mail that he thought people could learn “some elements of humor.” He suggested writers read people who do humor well, like Aimee Bender and George Saunders.

“I just read a great interview with Aimee Bender where she said it’s just much more fun to write from the point of view of somebody who is unlikable or at least a little crazy,” Housley told me.  Housley himself likes to play with oddball narrators, which is probably a lot like putting together a file of clips for a nonfiction writer: a deliberate step that shapes your material in ways that will force it toward something offbeat, witty, satirical or even flat out funny. Housley mentioned the journal Swivel, which publishes funny writing by women, as a potential market.

After 15 years of teaching, I lean toward Housley’s point-of-view and believe some level of humor can be learned just like any other aspect of the writing craft. For some people it comes more easily, because they already have a Smith frame of mind (I won’t explain that), but for others, they have to work at it and be willing to take a few risks with their voice or even their subject matter.

Smith wrote some off-color laugh-lines into the eulogy for her mother’s funeral.

“The minister was horrified, but it’s not like this particular scenario will ever play out again. Just don’t expect him to make idle chitchat with you after the service,” Smith remarked.